1 Comment

The modern "solution" involves a radical subversion of the medieval scenario. The "two-fold end" of man testified by medieval thinkers such as Thomas Aquinas does not mark a departure from St. Augustine, but a confirmation that there is fundamentally only one wisdom and one truth (contra certain Latin Averroists). Medieval theology does not involve a cage imposed ex machina, but a sphere of intelligibility (acquiring authority in its being revealed) vindicating natural reason, or signally natural reason's sacred/hidden destiny (St. Bonaventure's "reductio artium ad theologiam" discloses, rather than detract from freedom). Natural reason is rejected by the early prophets of the modern world in favour of a *mechanistic* reason that is not grounded in mystery, but in the absurd. The mystery of a divine coincidence between reason and authority/law is replaced by the fake/symbolic authority of autonomous reason, or by materialism making up its own laws to keep chaos at bay. Hence the "post-philosophical" situation we face, today. A far cry from the pre-philosophical barbarism Aquinas &co. respond to. Cf. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/jbQDTwrT6Y0

Expand full comment